The Game Plan - and Adjustments for Success

I'm surprised by how much I learn about Strategy Execution by watching football.  (No, that's not just something I tell my wife....).  

Let's start with the key concept that, to successfully execute a strategy, you need both clarity of vision (a clear understanding of what you want to accomplish - more on this topic at a later date) and a plan of how to get there.  Right now, let's focus on the plan. 

For a football team, the week prior to a game is spent understanding the competitive environment - which, in football, means the next opponent.  Coaches and players study film of past games, both your own team's and the oppositions, learning strengths and weaknesses, analyzing past performance in excrutiating detail.  The purpose is not to place blame for past problems, but to learn and improve.  

As this work progresses,  the coaches begin to develop the game plan.  What is the game plan? It's the specific plays - actions, activities, strategies, tactics - that the team intends to use to win the next game, based on their analysis of their opponent.  

Coaches build the game plan by making assumptions about what the opponent is going to do, through careful, in-depth study of what it has done in the past in similar situations and the results of those actions.  The game plan includes those plays that a team is best at executing.  The game plan also includes plays designed specifically to exploit the opponents' weaknesses.   The plan is then broken down, player by player, position by position, so that each person on the team knows exactly what he needs to do in order for the team to execute its game plan successfully.   

If the plan is executed as designed, the team expects success and, in the end, to win the game. Sound familiar?

Here's the key lesson:  The plan, however, is exactly that - it's a plan.   No matter how much time and effort the team spends preparing the plan for Saturday's or Sunday's game, the best are willing to throw the plan away if they get into the game and find out the plan isn't working.  

Sometimes, the plan doesn't work because the opponent doesn't do what was expected.  Sometimes, the designed plays aren't working the way they were designed, either from poor design, lack of execution, or unexpected responses from the opposition.  Whatever the reason, a team can't stick with a game plan that isn't working.  That's a recipe for failure. 

If you're a fan, you know about "half-time adjustments"  - the changes that coaches make to their game plans at half-time, based on the results of the first half of play. My (completely unscientific) observation is that the teams that win the most games, and are the most successful overall, are those teams that do the best job of adjusting their game plan in the midst of the game.   These adjustments can be of any type, but they have one thing in common:  An assumption that the coaches made when preparing the game plan turned out false  - so the game plan has to be adjusted based on new information.

This is where I'm going to stop for today - but only after making this point crystal clear.   A plan is great as a starting point, but success in strategy execution requires much more than a good plan.  It means being willing to adjust the plan in the heat of the battle, to recognize when the plan isn't working, or when key assumptions are no longer true.  It means measuring performance against clear metrics, and changing when performance is not meeting the desired goals.  And it means recognizing that the plan is only a means to an end - the end being winning the game.  

It may have been a great plan, but if it's not working - change it.  The goal is not to stay true to the plan.  The goal is to win the game.